50:50 at the Conservative Conference
Posted on 08/10/24
Written by Frances Lasok
The power of party conference comes from the cluster effect: the concentration of party members, journalists, politicians and lobbyists into one convention centre in one city. It offers an insight into mood. And this year, barely four months past a landslide Labour victory, the mood was strangely optimistic. The loss in July was a loss that everyone knew was coming. But unlike in 1997, Labour did not gain votes. Instead, we lost them. Electors frustrated with the chaos switched to Reform or stayed home. With the election over, the focus of this year’s conference was almost entirely on the next steps with the leadership election on the main stage, at the fringe events, supporters handing out merchandise around the Exhibition Hall.
But almost every room was over 70% men. Our Party trailblazed with the first female Prime Minister, then the second and then the third, but we haven’t percolated that success downwards. Listening to the Chair of the Candidates Committee on a Women2Win panel was raw and painful. Through a great deal of effort, the Conservative Party succeeded in getting the Candidates List to 40%* female. The selection longlists, formed from committees that must include one woman and overseen by the Candidates Committee, had balance: generally one woman in the final three, with occasional all-female finals. The overall numbers were decent because of appointments into the unwinnables, which provides a pool of experienced candidates for next time. But in the short term, the result after the election is a Parliamentary Party that contains just 24% women.
Fifty years ago, the aspirational electorate would accept a slate of blokes in suits. They won’t today. Polling shows we are failing amongst the working voters that should be our core, for a multitude of reasons that almost all boil down to failing on the core values of aspiration and competence. Excuses like “dealing with complaints is tough” and “gender equality is tough” won’t wash when our target vote works in business organisations that have overcome those challenges.
Gender equality is the canary in the coalmine for the big questions about talent, progress, and competence that a party that wants to take power has to resolve. Catching up with other candidates over coffee, the same stories emerged from the selections. High-calibre female candidates faced membership electorates that contained one or two women, sometimes none. Too many times, questions were asked that should have been stopped by a competent chair. Then there are the small number of true horror stories, the cases of overt misogyny that the Complaints system remains unable to handle. Every large organisation has these issues but we have too many, and we don’t deal competently with them when they arise. The electorate will not trust us to run the country if we cannot run ourselves.
There are positive signs. As Foreign Secretary, James Cleverly was a constant champion in words and actions for women and girls. When asked in a CPS event about restoring trust in politics, Tom Tugendhat gave an outstanding and unprompted answer on combatting misogyny, later calling the decline in proportion of female candidates unacceptable. Both answers are not only positive for women, they understand gender equality as part of the wider picture: the causal link between prosperity and the women’s education in global development, the link between organisational culture and organisational competence.
A candidate can win the membership election without tackling the causes of our gender imbalance, but that person can’t win the country. When we’ve come back from the wilderness, it has been under the leadership of those who formed us into a party of government, meeting the electorate’s expectations of what competence looks like. As with housing and planning, the gender equality question is only partly about the specific issue. The real question to the leadership candidates is this: “Do you want to be the next William Hague? Or the next Prime Minister?”
These are the views of the individual blogger and not of 50:50 Parliament as an organisation. 50:50 is cross-party and politically neutral.
*selected candidates were 27.2%