Press Release - RESET politics: we need to end the old boys' club to bring parliament into the 21st Century
Posted on 27/11/24
Campaign groups are calling for ambitious change in Parliament – following the revelation of outdated working practices and the poor mental health of many MPs
DATE: 12th, November 2024; A new report is calling for significant reforms to parliamentary working practices in an effort to end the “old boys club” culture of Westminster following the revelations of departing MPs.
The report by the organisations 50:50 Parliament and Compassion in Politics will be presented to the new Modernisation Committee and draws on the results of a 2024 survey of exiting MPs and interviews conducted together with the Apolitical Foundation and sponsored by the law firm Hogan Lovells.
132 MPs left Westminster in July this year. The results from the exit poll lift the lid on some very troubling working practices in the UK Parliament that are threatening the mental health of our politicians and further alienating the British public. The report seeks to address the inappropriate behaviour and outdated working practices in Parliament, as well as scale up mental health support. With public trust in politicians at an all-time low they also call for a ban on lying – or risk losing the British public altogether.
The calls for reform have received the backing of politicians, including former Labour spin doctor Alastair Campbell, current MP Kim Leadbeater, former MP Caroline Lucas, and former Home Secretary Amber Rudd.
The purpose of this report is to work with the welcome remit of the Modernisation Committee, laying out some urgent and practical steps to create a more inclusive, functional and gender-sensitive Parliament, to help protect MPs and staff and prevent any harm from arising, and to set a clear agenda for change that will also help improve public perceptions and trust of politics and politicians.
The data from the exit poll revealed that the overall picture of Parliament as a place of work is mixed, with some MPs stating that the role is an honour and privilege but with disturbing testimony of outdated and damaging work practices. 43% of the MPs surveyed admit that Parliament is “worse” than most other workplaces when it comes to standards of behaviour, with 26% saying it is “much worse”.
When problems arise, the general feeling is that there is not enough support in place to tackle them. Almost half, 45%, agreed that changes must be made to behaviour on the floor of the House of Commons. The data and personal experiences of MPs suggested a growing mental health crisis amongst Parliamentarians, which has been affected by inappropriate workplace practices and culture and exacerbated by social media attacks. Of the recommendations the report suggests, the largest amount of support was given to “providing better mental health support” (45%) and “increasing levels of personal protection” (also 45%). The report notes the alarming reality that these forms of “crisis” care are so urgently required in a system designed to govern the nation’s health and well-being.
Many reported experiencing extreme levels of anxiety and low mood because of their role as an MP, and several explained that they had considered taking their own lives. One MP and former Government Minister painted a very upsetting picture: “It’s been the most extreme experience of my life. The highs are wonderful. The lows are miserable. There’s very little in between. The collapse of public respect makes it an impossible job for the MP and their family. I had a nervous breakdown after my candidacy and again as a Minister.”
Amongst the recommendations, the organisations behind the report are calling for a review of the Whipping system to root out bullying, the introduction of electronic voting to guarantee impartiality and promote flexibility – and a debate on working hours and conditions in Parliament to promote more inclusive working practices. They also want to see an end to the tradition of bullying and jeering in Commons’ debates and more time given to Private Members’ Bills in order to hand more agency over to individual MPs.
Jennifer Nadel, Co-Director of Compassion in Politics, said: “Westminster still operates on procedures and practices that are hopelessly out of date. This government has an extraordinary opportunity to re-set politics. We need to significantly improve the working practices and culture at Westminster – for the benefit of MPs, staff, visitors, and those they serve. Time is up for the old boys club; we need to bring modern working practices into the Parliament workplace.”
There continues to be inequality at the top table – women are still under-represented in Parliament, despite progress at the last election, along with people from Black and ethnically minoritised backgrounds (global majority) and disabled people. It is widely accepted that women face additional barriers compared to men to taking part in public life, including shouldering the higher burden of childcare and experiencing misogyny and harassment. Women from the 50:50 community have cited the perceived ‘misogynistic environment’ in Parliament, above abuse and harassment, as the main reason they would not currently consider standing for Parliament. 87% of the women MPs surveyed said that their gender had influenced their experience of being an MP.
Lyanne Nicholl, CEO of 50:50 Parliament, said: “Parliament, and women’s representation within it, has come on leaps and bounds, but the job is far from done. Without significant changes, we are still a long way off from equal representation in Parliament. We support the Modernisation Committee’s commitment to a Parliament that will inspire future generations, and we hope to work with them to ensure that Parliament works for women. When women aren’t in the room, they are written out of policy-making in the most devastating ways. To ensure that we continue to progress with women’s rightful representation and not regress, we need to ensure a workplace that supports women.”
Alastair Campbell, former head of communications for Labour, said: “We have a new government whose election slogan was “Change” and nowhere is that more needed than in politics itself. There are so many ways in which politics and Parliament can and should be modernised, and this report is an important contribution to the debate about what these changes should be. It is in the interest of both public and politicians that we build on the things that work and change the things that don’t.”
Former Home Secretary Amber Rudd said: “Anything which encourages further introspection on whether we have the balance right yet in Parliament, between tradition and functionality, between flexibility and rigour, and between Government business and agency for all MPs – can only be a good thing. I also support 50:50 Parliament and Compassion in Politics commitment to trying to ensure that the Parliament they are encouraging women into is as inclusive and safe as it can be”.
Recommendations from the report include:
- Review flexible and inclusive working best practices from other parliaments and organisations with a commitment in principle to adopt best practice: including but not limited to, job shares, multiple forms of childcare offering, work/life balance initiatives.
- Bring forward a debate on the working culture in Parliament, to focus on gender and diversity sensitivity, the online abuse associated with the role, the impact on family life and mental health.
- Modernise the language used in parliament
- Increase the agency for MPs, particularly opposition members and backbenchers, by establishing a House Business Committee for clarity on working hours and taking measures to prevent the ‘talking out’ of private members bills.
- Establish an independent Human Resources department to oversee the employment of MPs’ staff and ensure gold standard care and policies with stringent policies of zero tolerance of sexual harrassment and bullying
- Promote constructive, respectful debate.
- Return to the use of electronic voting in the Commons.
- Launch a consultation on the conduct of the Whipping system.
- Introduce a rule to ensure honesty and transparency.
- Put the Members’ and Ministerial Code of Conduct on a statutory footing.
The report argues that modernisation is vital if Parliament is to:
- To deliver a House of Commons that reflects, and is able to represent, the diversity of the British public
- To improve public trust in politicians and, by extension, the UK’s democratic process
- To meet the international democratic norms of gender sensitivity and gender equality, including the 2022 Kigali declaration and the UN Sustainable Development Goals 5 and 16
- To address public perception of an elitist ‘old boys’ club that does not welcome or value diversity and equal representation.
- Minimise levels of division and hostility between individuals and parties.
- To role model non-aggressive conduct and cultures, as aggression amongst MPs may feed aggression towards politicians outside of Parliament;
- To take the opportunity to reset public perceptions about, and enhance political engagement with, Parliament and its elected politicians
- To meet the basic duty of care to support and protect British elected representatives and their staff.
- To address the worsening mental health crisis amongst MPs, such that those high levels of sensitivity/empathy are not driven out of the political space.
- To show that Parliament is responding to public concerns about transparency, honesty, and self-regulation.
Notes to editor:
For all media enquiries contact:
Tel:07756 525 004
About the research:
The report prepared for the Committee by the organisations 50:50 Parliament and Compassion in Politics draws on the results of a 2024 survey of exiting MPs(sponsored by law firm Hogan Lovells) and interviews which informed the BBC Radio 4 Documentary ‘Broken Politicians; Broken Politics’. conducted together with the Apolitical Foundation,, presented by Jennifer Nadel and produced and conceptualised by Daniel Tetlow
Methodology
An invitation to complete an Exit Survey was sent to all Members of Parliament who, by March 2024, had announced that they would not be re-standing for election. A copy of the survey, which was completed online, can be found at the end of this report.
Data
132 MPs stood down at the last election. 24 MPs took part in the survey. Of those, 23 provided demographic characteristics. It should be noted that there’s a consensus amongst academic researchers that response rates for UK politicians are notoriously low and 18% (24 from 132) is not below average.
Where we footnote ‘from second dataset’, this pertains to an expanded survey which was sent to half of respondents, with a couple of additional questions added.
Additional qualitative data is also included from interviews collected in the aforementioned BBC Documentary.
- Gender: 6 (26%) of the respondents were female; 17 (74%) male.
- Parties represented:
- Labour: 6
- SNP: 3
- Conservative: 13
- Plaid Cymru: 1
We acknowledge that this is a small, self-selecting, group of MPs. However, there is clear qualitative evidence of detrimental norms and practices which make the job of MP more difficult.